The right and wrong about the non-Kashmiri students of NIT Srinagar who went violent recently

Quick background

India lost to West Indies last week in the T20 Cricket tournament. Some Kashmiri students reportedly burst firecrackers (can be assumed as celebration for India’s loss). This infuriated the non-local students who then took out a pro-India march in the campus and raised anti-Pakistan and pro-India slogans.

The local Kashmiri students consequently carried out a counter-protest march in which they allegedly raised pro-Pakistan slogans. They also hoisted a green flag in the campus.

With this, things went out of hand and the two groups started beating each other up (500+ non-Kashmiris vs ~70 Kashmiris). The non-Kashmiri students also harassed teachers (one teacher was allegedly beaten up) and damaged college infrastructure. They also assaulted a local courier boy after he refused to say “Bharat mata ki jai”.

Police was called in and teargas shelling and cane charge was used to finally disperse the students. The institute had to be shut down for few days (till it reopened recently).

(Source1, Source2)

What is RIGHT about the non Kashmiri students of NIT Srinagar who went violent recently?

If you love your country and your cricket team, it is okay to get infuriated with a fellow Indian when he / she celebrates the loss of the nation that he / she belongs to. And though ideally, violence should be avoided (and is condemned), shouldn’t the Kashmiri students be blamed for instigating the other students?


What is WRONG about the non Kashmiri students of NIT Srinagar who went violent recently?

India’s defeat in a cricket match gives relief to some Kashmiris who despise Indian military’s power across the state (Source1,Source2). Is it a crime to celebrate India’s loss, if you are an Indian national? If non-Kashmiris have problems with Kashmiri students of their college bursting firecrackers, shouldn’t they talk about it, report it, and try to convince their batchmates otherwise? India – the country, belongs to both, whether they hate it or like it!

Getting angry is not a good enough reason to get violent and destroy property. It only further alienates the Kashmiris as reflected by the following reactions:

  • Kashmir University Students’ Union (KUSU) believes this NIT episode “is a glaring example of how the Indian state colonises even the campuses and institutes in the Valley and makes these hostile for Kashmiri students”. (Source)
  • Terming the incident as “intolerable”, Chairman Hurriyat Conference (G), Syed Ali Geelani said that it is “investigating” the involvement of “state machinery” in the NIT clashes. (Source)
  • Engineer Rashid, an Independent MLA of Jammu and Kashmir Assembly warned of “dire consequences” if acts of “harassment, torture and humiliation of Kashmiri students, in and outside the state, is not stopped.” (Source)

We at neutral image don’t want to judge either the non-Kashmiris who went violent nor the Kashmiri students who don’t like their own country. We just want to present both side’s perspective here and leave it to you to draw your own conclusions.

Feature image source.

Original post by Neha Kirpal, edited by Amrit Vatsa.


2 thoughts on “The right and wrong about the non-Kashmiri students of NIT Srinagar who went violent recently

  1. Poonam Kirpal / April 6, 2016 at 6:37 am

    As we are a democratic country and have the freedom to do whatever we want we must exercise our rights with restrain, keeping our responsibilities in mind. In my opinion if an act of ours displeases or triggers off violence we should avoid such behaviour as responsible citizens especially publicly

  2. Pushkar Dwivedi / April 9, 2016 at 12:46 pm

    As Far As I see It, Kashmiri People’s Celebration of W.Indies Team is Pretty fine ..Even, chanting of Bharat Mata Ki Jai By Non Kashmiri People Is fine And Both was Okay. But, as A Retaliation by Kashmiri Students By Chanting”Pakistan Zindabad” is Definitely not fine and Even Dangerous And Had The Huge Potential To instigate Violence between Kashmiri And Non Kashmiri Students. Damage of Public Property is Condemnable No Matter Who does that. They should be punished for sure. But, KASHMIRI STUDENTS WERE DEFINITELY ON THE WRONG SIDE BY CHANTING PAKISTAN ZINDABAD..and Anyone Who has Little Respect for Respect for Their soldiers And Polices will get Offended by hearing Pro Pakistan chats (When specially done for countering Pro Indian Shoutings). Hopefully The Indian State And JnK state Will be Fair while Investigating the Matter And Bring the culprits To justice.
    Jai Hind.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *